Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Sharks in the Dark: Deep Sea Cold Vents as Shark Nurseries

This is a pretty good example of an article I wrote for BioSc 494: Popular Science Journalism where I struggled to figure out how to relate really neat science to a college audience. While I wish I could say 'This is super duper cool because SHARKS and COLD VENTS aaaah', that's not a very effective way to communicate. I ran into the issue during round table review of not being able to use the word 'elasmobranch' as often as I'd like. This appeared in the Fall 2011 issue of Tigra Scientifica which can be downloaded here.


The sun provides energy for nearly everything on Earth, although some alien exceptions exist.  The sulfur and hydrogen loving bacteria of Yellowstone or the methane worms of deep-sea vent communities are just two examples. There might be more familiar species that also don’t use solar energy.  In the September Marine Ecology Progress Series, Dr. Tina Treude from Leibniz Institute of Marine Sciences in Germany and colleagues discovered shark and skate (a flat fish similar to a ray) egg capsules at two deep sea cold seep sites and discovered fossil evidence of similar behavior in Washington. This indicates that these fish use cold seeps as nurseries.
Like hydrothermal vents, cold seeps are locations in the deep sea that provide energy to a community that cannot rely on photosynthesis. They look very much like the vents; however, temperatures at cold seeps are usually less than 10 degrees Celsius. Instead of geothermal heat, energy is released in the form of hydrocarbons like oil and methane that oozes, or “seeps” out of fissures in the sea floor. Initially extreme species of bacteria colonize the area, then mussels and eventually tubeworms can move in to form a community. More complex organisms may eventually follow.
Dr. Treude and her team used remotely controlled devices to examine two locations: a mud volcano in the Mediterranean Sea and a cold seep off the coast of Chile.  At the Mediterranean Sea site, hundreds of shark egg cases were strewn across a dense field of tubeworms. Based on the size and shape, the team guessed they belong to deep-water catsharks. In addition to the egg cases, anemones, shrimps, a squid, and other fish were found living in the tubeworm field. At the Chilean site, hundreds to possibly thousands of large skate egg cases were discovered on a large sheet of rock exposed to open ocean. The sheer number of embryos and a possibly pregnant skate seen at the site indicate this may be a nursery for generations of the bottom-dwelling fish.
In the second part of the study, the research team looked at the fossil record, taking samples from a 35 million year old seep deposit in Washington state. Fossils of mussels dominated the deposit while tubeworms and snails were also present. The researchers collected 30 fossilized egg cases and fragments. Based on the shape of the fossilized capsules they determined that the egg capsules belonged to some species of deep-water catshark.  Fossil tooth evidence proves that catsharks lived in that part of the ocean at that time.
Putting together the prehistoric evidence with modern observations, Dr. Treude concluded that cold seeps serve as nurseries for elasmobranches, which are cartilaginous fishes like sharks, skates, and rays. These locations provide protected and ventilated holdfasts for the egg cases to cling to. While more research needs to be done, Dr. Treude suspects that the presence of small fishes, crustaceans, and mollusks could provide food for newborn elasmobranches. While not fully understood the presence of a large predator in a nonsolar-based community is intriguing because higher level predators are normally found in a solar-based food chain. Humans have considered using methane hydrate deposits from the ocean floor as an alternative fuel source. If a baby shark can gain enough energy to live eating chemosynthetic organisms, perhaps humans can use and farm extreme bacteria for fuel.
Treude, et al. “Elasmobranch egg capsules associated with modern and ancient cold seeps: a nursery for marine deep-water predators” Marine Ecology Progress Series. September 15h, 2011.

No comments:

Post a Comment